The story of the akedah is the greatest, most magnificent, and most deeply meaningful of all. The akedah, or binding of isaac my jewish learning. The ancient argument was not silenced, that at the akedah there had been no consummation of the act in christian kingdoms, in the middle ages, when the taunt was frequently directed against israel that the akedah was no sacrifice in truth, but only a hint of what was to come, the completed act in the days of jesus. According to our lost parable, that is the midrashic version of the akedah, isaac died on the altar. The binding of isaac, known in hebrew as the akedah, is one of the best known and most troubling stories in the bible. An angel stopped abraham when he was about to slay his son and replaced isaac with a ram. Gods demand that abraham sacrifice his longawaited and beloved son as a burnt offering on one of the mountains of the land of moriah gen 22. Sugarmans book is a welcome contribution to the maturing field of levinas studies. All that we have, even our own lives and those of the ones most dear to us, belong ultimately to god, who gave them to us in the first place. This, then, is the power of the akedah and, for me, the reason for its. The akedah in jewish thought forthcoming from jpsuniversity of nebraska press in 2020. This hebrew bible was edited by esteemed translator and scholar, rabbi a. Niggun akedah is an ashkenazi melody firmly associated with the binding of isaac, which was sung to texts in both hebrew and yiddish.
Each rosh hashanah, the akedah the binding of isaac, abrahams near sacrifice of his son isaac at gods behest, highlights for us the impenetrable paradox of affirming a good, omnipotent god who causes bad things to happen to good people. Even the sounding of the shofar on rosh hashanah is said to be based on the akedah. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer no. Particularly within jewish faith and thought the story has been reflected. Introduction the story of the akedah, or the binding of isaac genesis 22, is a prominent motif in israeli literature and art. Aug 30, 2004 this torah portion has inspired countless poems, and not a few books of philosophy. The akedah myth features as a code word used by israeli society to talk with itself about itself and its troubled fate. The meaning of the akedah in israeli culture and jewish tradition.
This account of a divine test of sacrifice and devotion has inspired many to explore the tension between ones capacity for selfsacrifice and ones doubts about its worthiness and consequences. The biblical story of the akedah abrahams nearsacrifice of isaac at the command of godhas been a wellspring for the most diverse theological commentary, from the talmud to existentialism. Aaron has served as a visiting professor at the hebrew university in. Having prepared the altar, upon which he bound his beloved son, abraham lifted the knife to sacrifice isaac. In it, god orders abraham to sacrifice his son, isaac, on mount moriah. Footnote, an israeli film that won best screenplay at cannes in 2011 and. The footnotes are more meaningful, and the commentary is improved.
In genesis 22, we read that god commands abraham to offer up his only son isaac upon an altar. Kaminsky rabbinic and even prerabbinic texts like the book of jubilees suggest that abraham successfully navigated a number of trials or tests, including the akedah, the binding of isaac recounted in gen 22. He has published nearly twenty novels and books on a wide range of jewish. The chief note of the book of isaiah is varietyvariety of tone, of style, of thought, and of historical background. The meaning of the akedah in israeli culture and jewish tradition 47. The akedah, a primary symbol in jewish thought and art. The narrative in the twentysecond chapter of the book of genesis, in which abraham is instructed by god to offer up his son isaac as a burnt offering, is known in the jewish tradition as the akedah,1.
Editors of commentary magazine the condition of jewish. A scholar known for bringing the materials of the ancient near east to bear on the interpretation of biblical texts, sarna has created a detailed introduction to and commentary on ten of the psalms. His last book was esther in ancient jewish thought cambridge university press, 2014, and his next is unbinding isaac. Jewish commentators offered many different answers such as, god only said to bring him up genesis rabbah, god does contradict himself at times ibn ezra, theakedah was a punishment for making a treaty with avimelech rashbam, or that it was all just to show future generations a true model of faithfulness radak. On the mountain god will look upon isaacs ashes heaped up and standing for atonement. Paul is the yehezkel kaufman professor emeritus of bible at the hebrew university of jerusalem and chair of the dead sea scrolls foundation. Elohim as the divine name with glosses by the redactor r, hence also the use of the tetragrammaton.
There are also corrections to the hebrew text, and clearer typesetting. Jts torah online jewish theological seminary of america. One says he actually died, and spent three years in eden being put back together again. In this companion volume to his widely read and highly acclaimed jewish new testament, he offers an exciting and original way of understanding the new testament from a jewish point of view. It has been preserved for us and transmitted to us by the ancient jewish commentaries on the scriptures, that is the midrash, and indeed, the hebrew word for this kind of parable is midrash. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle. In some of these prayers, the jewish people appeal to gods mercy with abraham during the akedah as they seek gods divine forgiveness for themselves today. The akedah, a primary symbol in jewish thought and art by jo milgrom author visit amazons jo milgrom page. Moberly durham few stories within the old testament have received more commentary than the story of the testing of abrahamwidely known as the akedah, the binding of isaacin gen. Struggling with the dilemma of a god who commands abraham to sacrifice his chosen son. Suggestions for further reading on jewish study of the akedah. Not only a story of abrahams devotion to god, this biblical episode reflects the classic tension between generations. He has written many books focusing on his reconstruction of the redaction history of genesis through kings. The logos free book of the month promotion offers a heavyweight commentary from eerdmans.
In doing so, he is going back to the biblical account which has occupied a substantial place in jewish thought. The problem of the akedah in jewish thought in kierkegaards fear and trembling. Ultimate values and the akedah story jewish theological seminary. However, please bring back the amazing interactive coding, which allowed a person to read in order and concentrate on the words, and almost gave the feeling that people were praying along. Jewish bible commentaries merrimack valley havurah. Plus theres a ton of midrash interpretive story on the akedah. Abraham here exemplifies obedience and isaac embodies the martyr in judaism. Our religion is often countercultural, critiquing american norms and mores, even those we find congenial.
The story of the akedah, abrahams binding and near sacrifice of his son, isaac, is one of the most enigmatic passages of the bible. The midrash interpretive text does not see this as coincidence, and we are told that the cry of the shofar is the tears of sarah. When jude wrote this book, the church was under heavy persecution from rome and the jewish leaders. The akedah narrative is generally attributed to source e which uses. This torah portion has inspired countless poems, and not a few books of philosophy. Abraham, together with isaac, makes the journey to mount moriah. Berman uses his training as a psychologist and his personal experience as a father to craft his intensive inquiry into the akedah. Early christian preaching sometimes accepted jewish interpretations of the binding of isaac without elaborating. Isaacs sacrifice and national narra redwood city, ca.
Sforno s elaboration of this thought commentary to gen. Part 1 gods role in the akedah gods devastating request. The binding of isaac, known in hebrew as the akedah, is one of the best. It took twentythree books to cover the new testament, and they were published in two bound volumes in 1989. Jewish american heritage month tzvi fishman the blogs. One of the joys of working at the jewish theological seminary is the ability to take courses from arguably the greatest jewish studies faculty in the world.
Jude wrote this book exclusively to fight against the apostasy that was defiling the church and defectors of the faith who were building apostate churches. An introduction to the book of psalms nahum sarna, schocken books, 1993. He is the author of the first book of god, and the multivolume kernel to canon series, with books like jacobs journey and mosess mission. Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. This theurgic reading of the akedah opens the possibility for rashi to offer an even more radical image of what moves god toward mercy, in order that it will be said on this day in all generations to come. In other contexts, the account has been used to demonstrate that god does not require a human sacrifice. The akedah, or binding of isaac is the torah portion that most people relate with rosh hashanah.
Ramadan tv series about gulf jews ignites controversy. I recommend that people search siddur to bring up the online siddur with commentary. In the heart of torah, rabbi shai helds torah essaystwo for each weekly portionopen new horizons in jewish biblical commentary. In israel, with so much of the culture based upon both regular and almost universal military experience imposed upon the youth as well as wars serving as decisive markers in cultural developments, the akedah continues to be a powerful theme in contemporary discourse. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. A modern commentary has a much better layout, better translations and better organization than the previous version. David baumgardt here examines the various meanings that have been attached to the story, one of the great pillars of the jewish religious tradition, and offers his own reading. Jewish tradition completely misunderstands the significance of the akedah.
Last year, i audited a course on biblical grammar in the book of genesis taught by one of this generations greatest bible scholars. The akedah reminds us that the torah of abraham disputes the torah of complacency, ease, and selfsatisfaction. Logos free book of the month for may 2020 eerdmans. Illuminated page of isaiah from a manuscript bible, said to be of the twelfth century. Rashis reading of the akedah journal of textual reasoning. From a careful reading of his commentary on the akedah we can observe how carefully rashi.
Like abraham and isaac in the story of the akedah isaac is often depicted as a consenting adult in postbiblical jewish tradition, during this time the community stands before god and openly acknowledges that god has an ultimate claim on our lives and that god can choose to exercise that claim at any time. The akedah became in jewish thought the supreme example of selfsacrifice in obedience. The problem of the akedah in jewish thought books of louis. Sep 26, 2014 your personal story meaning from the akedah we are about to read the story known as the akedah, the binding of isaac. This story has been elaborated in jewish lore with a multitude of moral applications. Abraham bound his son isaac on an altar at moriah, as he had been instructed by god. Most modern commentaries tend to be critical of abraham, but a recent popular film that i believe is a midrash on the akedah story takes a different view. Splendor or radiance is the foundational work in the literature of jewish mystical thought known as kabbalah. It is the story of abraham hearing gods command and taking his son on a journey to mount moriah, to offer isaac as a sacrifice to the eternal.
A preface provides an overview of levinass life, approach, and place in contemporary jewish thought. Whats different in this version of jewish commentary on the messiah. The prayer book the siddur judaism, torah and jewish info. Since that time, freeaccess manuscript libraries have appeared online, supplying hebrew sources for the rabbinic quotes we had found in english only. Though isaac is the one being bound, the story is referred to as a test of abraham. For example, hippolytus of rome says in his commentary on the song of songs, the blessed isaac became desirous of the anointing and he wished to sacrifice himself for the sake of the world on the song 2. Each volume is the work of a scholar who stands at the pinnacle of his field.
Before making aliyah in 1984, tzvi fishman taught creative writing at the nyu school of the arts. At the opening of the book, motta transfers command of the post to giddy and says. The akedah in israeli poetry and art the yiddish book. Our faculty and teachers bring the depth and breadth of jts learning directly to you through a rich collection of contemporary jewish content.
David stern, a messianic jew living in jerusalem, speaks to these and other issues in the jewish new testament commentary. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. Held probes the portions in bold, original, and provocative ways. The woodstock jewish congregation family school provides a loving, welcoming, and enthusiastic environment in which jewish children and their parents from all backgrounds learn to practice judaism in meaningful and enlivening ways. Oct 23, 2015 this torah reading in hebrew is from genesis 19. Many of these texts touch directly upon the biblical story, while others refer to the traumatic memory of the crusades, and to other themes, as will be shown below. In fact, jewish communities worldwide read this passage on rosh hashanah the jewish new year along with prayers called selichot, prayers for forgiveness. Oct 04, 2012 the ancient argument was not silenced, that at the akedah there had been no consummation of the act in christian kingdoms, in the middle ages, when the taunt was frequently directed against israel that the akedah was no sacrifice in truth, but only a hint of what was to come, the completed act in the days of jesus. The jps torah commentary series guides readers through the words and ideas of the torah. Our people, originally published in 1946, was the first jewish history book for the english speaking reader. At the core of rashis fusion of these three elements into his commentary is the reality that the narrative of the akedah was linked from a very early period in rabbinic literature to the holy day of rosh hashanah. How could god promise to make abrahams descendants as numerous as the stars of the heavens, and then order abraham to take your sonand go to the. This midrashic feature of bringing satan into the akedah story predates the rabbinic era, and can be found in the book of jubilees ca.
Rabbinic exegetes attempts to explain the context, meaning, and value. Free online bible library jewish commentary on the bible. The binding of isaac opens with a careful reading of genesis 22, taking time to discuss crucial words and phrases. Amid countless commentaries on the akedah, aaron kollers powerful, gracefully written work is brilliant, refreshing, and new. Jewish and christian interpretations of the akedah genesis. Mention must also be made of isaac arama 143094, whose aqedhah, his commentary on the pentateuch homiletical in style, was the standard book for the jewish pulpit for centuries, much esteemed by the christian world, and is still much read. Editors of commentary magazine the condition of jewish belief a symposium 1st edition 1st printing hardcover new york jason aronson, inc. The previous version, posted at rz for most of 2012, had been compiled after more than 4 years of research. Binding referring to the binding of isaac as related in genesis 22. It is part of the shacharit morning service on shabbat and is also read on holidays. The reader emerges with a deeper understanding of both the torah and the philosophy of a key jewish thinker.
For the month of may, you can add shalom pauls commentary on isaiah 4066 in the eerdmans critical commentary. A couple of folks commented that in my list of 20 th century genocides, i failed to list maos cultural revolution or the 3040 million killed by stalin in. The problem of the akedah in jewish thought books of. Online siddur a top jewish web resource thanks for your excellent site. In one, berman traces the history of dogma in judaism, showing that many great rabbis, before and after maimonides, did not accept principle number 8, at. The complete tanakh tanach hebrew bible the jewish. The story of abrahams supreme test of faith is recited every morning as a prelude to shacharit morning services and at the start of every jewish year i. Yoreh has taught at ben gurion university and american jewish university. When joseph was a slave in potiphars household god was with him and gave him success in his work, thereby enabling him to win his masters favor.
The problem of the akedah in jewish thought books of louis jacobs. Read today, it still provides a comprehensive outline of jewish. Moshe shamir, a leading writer from the founders generation, excelled in formulating its meaning in israeli culture. Discover jesus in the binding of isaac genesis 22 and the. Reference to this story appears throughout the rosh hashanah liturgy. Harvesting generations of scholarship in bible, rabbinics, and jewish thought, medieval and modern, he deftly inlays their voices in. The jewish bible with a modern english translation and rashis commentary english translation of the entire tanakh tanach with rashis commentary. The following commentaries on my jewish learning address the binding of isaac. He mines talmud and midrashim, great writers of world literature, and astute commentators of other religious backgrounds to ponder fundamental questions about god. Jtss extensive online torah resources reflect todays most compelling conversations, research, and teaching from leaders in jewish studyall available for learners around the world to explore and enjoy. Here are the instructions how to enable javascript in your web browser. At times, isaac has served as the symbol of jewish martyrs. The narrative in the twentysecond chapter of the book of genesis, in which abraham is instructed by god to offer up his son isaac as a burnt offering, is known in. Artscroll jewish books, judaica, talmud, chumash mishnah for full functionality of this site it is necessary to enable javascript.
955 632 1407 452 213 1014 746 433 1187 1062 385 885 516 370 1118 1156 685 1518 1353 346 331 756 1212 193 95 501 60 1443 557 274 948 668 335